24 Beef Pot Pie Recipes For a Slew of Comforting Dinners! 

July 10, 2024
Written by Kristy J. Norton

If you imagine that beef pot pies are boring and predictable, think again! These recipes show you how to make beef pot pies that are flavorful, hearty, and that can suit a variety of taste buds. Go ahead and check them out now! 

beef pot pie

1. Leftover Roast Beef Pie

As the name suggests, this pie is an excellent choice when you have leftovers and don’t know what to do with them. It is super easy to make with the addition of beef gravy, frozen veggies, and store bought crust. This recipe also manages to be cozy and delicious! 

Get the recipe here: https://cookinginthemidwest.com/blog/leftover-roast-beef-pot-pie/

2. Beef Wellington Pot Pie

If you are looking for a tasty and comforting pot pie, then look no further than this recipe! The meat and mushrooms are simmered in a gorgeous stock and red wine gravy until it is perfectly tender. Then, the filling is packed into a buttery, flaky pie for the finishing touches! 

Get the recipe here: https://www.giftofhospitality.com/beef-wellington-pot-pie/

3. Guinness Beef Pot Pie

It doesn’t get any heartier than this pot pie! The beef veggies, frozen veggies, and aromatics are all cooked in a delicious Guiness-based broth until they are just right. Next up, you roll puff pastry over the stew and cook until buttery and golden! 

Get the recipe here: https://picturetherecipe.com/recipes/guinness-beef-pot-pie/

4. Ground Beef Pot Pie

Want to make a cozy pot pie on a weeknight? Well, this is the recipe for you! The ground beef, cream of potato soup, and frozen veggies can be cooked up incredibly quickly. This means that once the beef is browned, the filling can be baked at the same time as the pie crust! 

Get the recipe here: https://lemonsandzest.com/simple-beef-pot-pie/

5. Braised Beef Pot Pie with Biscuit Topping

Not a fan of puff pastry? That’s not a problem because this beef pot pie has a delicious homemade biscuit topping instead! Of course, this pot pie has a lot more going for it – the beef and veggies are cooked in broth and orange juice for a tasty and tender filling! 

Get the result here: https://www.rockrecipes.com/braised-beef-pot-pie-biscuit-topping/

6. Creamy Beef Pot Pie

If you are on the lookout for an oh-so-creamy recipe then look no further! This beef pot pie is made ultra creamy thanks to the addition of gorgonzola crumbles and cream. The pie is further bulked up with tons of veggies and a chopped up biscuit topping. 

Get the recipe here: https://grilledcheesesocial.com/2024/02/26/beef-pot-pie-gorgonzola/

7. Skillet Beef Pot Pie

It doesn’t get any easier than this skillet pot pie! Everything comes together in a single skillet and you even bake the pot pie in the same pan. Also, this pot pie only takes about half an hour to cook. It is still creamy and delicious though! 

Get the recipe here: https://www.julieseatsandtreats.com/easy-skillet-beef-pot-pie-recipe/

8. Instant Pot Beef Pot Pie

If you are looking for a more set it and forget it recipe, this will become your go-to dish! Here, the filling comes together in an Instant Pot so you don’t have to worry about watching over it. For the final touches, the filling is topped off with puff pastry and baked in an oven. 

Get the recipe here: https://www.favfamilyrecipes.com/instant-pot-beef-pot-pie/

9. Ground Beef and Mushroom Pot Pie

Hearty and delicious, this ground beef and mushroom pie is a great option for anyone who doesn’t like much gravy or sauce with their pie. This is a drier version of a pot pie but is still tender, savory, and the perfect comfort meal. 

Get the recipe here: https://lifearoundthetable.ca/ground-beef-and-mushroom-pie/

10. Mini Beef Pot Pies

This is a great option for a dinner party or just when you want each person to have their own individual pie. Here, each section of pastry is placed in the well of a muffin pan and topped off with the beef filling. Then, the pastry is wrapped around the beef and baked until golden brown. 

Get the recipe here: https://realfoodbydad.com/beef-pot-pies/

11. Steak and Mushroom Pot Pie

Steak and mushrooms all cooked in broth and fresh herbs – is there anything better than that? This is a great option for a filling and savory meal, especially when this silky stew is topped off with a buttery pie crust. 

Get the recipe here: https://simply-delicious-food.com/steak-mushroom-pot-pie/

12. Leftover Prime Rib Phyllo Pot Pie

This pot pie recipe will serve you well if you are looking for a different take on the pie crust. Instead of being topped off with puff pastry, this pot pie uses phyllo pastry which offers a more delicate and crunchy finish to the pie. 

Get the recipe here: https://www.plattertalk.com/prime-rib-phyllo-pot-pie/

13. Steak Pot Pie

If you want a more flavorful and chunkier pie, then look no further than this recipe. Here, the steak is browned and cut into chunks before being mixed into a creamy filling. The filling is topped off with crescent pastry dough before being baked to a golden brown. 

Get the recipe here: https://www.delish.com/cooking/recipe-ideas/a29701597/steak-pot-pie-recipe/

14. Beef Pot Pie with Cheddar Stout Crust

A lot of recipes focus on the beef pot pie filling more than anything else. This recipe, however, is the perfect choice for anyone who also wants to liven up their pie crust. This homemade pie crust also includes cheese and beer for that additional burst of flavor! 

Get the recipe here: https://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/food-network-kitchen/beef-potpies-with-cheddar-stout-crust-recipe-2111732

15. Mennonite Country Beef Pot Pie 

Want a more old fashioned take on your beef pot pie? Well, this is certainly an interesting recipe to try out! Here, the homemade pie crust dough is cut into squares and dropped into the traditionally prepared beef stew. It is a cozy and unique take on pot pie! 

Get the recipe here: https://www.justapinch.com/recipes/main-course/beef/menonite-country-old-fashioned-beef-pot-pie.html

16. Steak and Ale Pot Pie 

This steak and ale pot pie is perfect for anyone who likes depth and layers of flavor to their food. The ale, balsamic vinegar, steak sauce, and more all make this a really delicious pie that is also easy to prepare.

Get the recipe here: https://grandbaby-cakes.com/steak-and-ale-pot-pie/

17. Cornbread Pot Pie

This is another fun and delicious take on the pot pie topping. Here, meat, beans, and corn are all topped off with a cornbread batter. This makes for a hearty meal that can also be prepared in a little over an hour!

Get the recipe here: https://www.inhabitedkitchen.com/cornbread-pot-pie/

18. Cornbread Chili Pot Pie 

Want to take the flavor factor to another level? This is the way to do it! This pot pie has a savory, slightly spicy filling that tastes just like chili! It is all surrounded by a moist and delicious cornbread pastry.

Get the recipe here: https://www.thefoodinmybeard.com/cornbread-chili-pies/

19. Beef Pot Pie Topped with Polenta 

If you are the type to experiment with your pot pies, you are going to love this take! Here, you top your pot pie with a cheesy polenta topping. Best of all, since you use instant polenta, you cut down on the time and fuss involved with this dish!

Get the recipe here: https://www.taste.com.au/recipes/polenta-topped-beef-pot-pies/305ebe7a-1211-47f0-9cbb-57e6348364dd

20. Mexican Beef Pot Pie

This beef filling is so flavorful since it is cooked in tomato sauce! The pie is further bulked up by corn and beans, making this a pretty healthy meal. Oh, and don’t forget to top up your pie with a cornbread recipe that also includes cheese and green chiles! 

Get the recipe here: https://www.mostlyhomemademom.com/mexican-pot-pie/

21. BBQ Beef Pot Pie 

This recipe is just perfect for the summer! The beef and veggies are cooked in salsa and BBQ sauce, making for a truly flavorful dish. The pot pie is then topped off with cornbread and a layer of cheese – just delicious! 

Get the recipe here: https://www.tasteofhome.com/recipes/skillet-bbq-beef-potpie/

22. Smoked Brisket Pot Pie 

If you want to add a smoky flavor to your pot pie, this is the best way to do it! Chopped brisket and veggies are cooked in a stew before being topped with puff pastry and then smoked on the grill. This is such a delicious take on the pot pie! 

Get the recipe here: https://www.traeger.com/recipes/brisket-pot-pie

23. Marsala Mushroom and Beef Pot Pie 

Want a slightly fancier take on your pot pie? Then this is the recipe that will do it for you. The marsala wine adds depth to the beef, mushroom, and soup filling. It is also great for softening the meat so that the filling is nice and tender! 

Get the recipe here: https://blackberrybabe.com/2021/02/05/marsala-mushroom-and-beef-pot-pie/

24. Brisket Burnt Ends Pot Pie 

If burnt ends are the favorite part of the barbecue, then this is the recipe for you. Here, the burnt ends are cooked up in a savory veggie filling. Then, the filling is placed in a pie crust and cooked until golden brown! 

Get the recipe here: https://www.atbbq.com/blogs/recipes/brisket-burnt-ends-pot-pie

You never have to make beef pot pie the same way twice again! These pot pie recipes let you get as creative as you want and to wow your family and guests alike! 

By Kristy J. Norton
I'm Kristy – a chef and connoisseur of all things BBQ! You can find me either in my kitchen (or someone else's) or at a big outdoor barbecue surrounded by friends and family. In both my professional and personal life I’ve picked up more than a few tips and tricks for turning out delicious food. I consider it a privilege to share it with others!
Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Pitmaster Central is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for website owners to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon (.com, .co.uk, .ca etc) and any other website that may be affiliated with Amazon Service LLC Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Keep Reading
Copyright 2024 Pitmaster Central, all rights reserved.