10 Best Mail Order Steaks to Sink Your Teeth Into

June 23, 2023
Written by Kristy J. Norton

The best mail order steak company is Snake River Farms. It offers excellent quality, has a wide selection of steaks to choose from, and ships the steaks to you quickly as well.

I only really began to consider mail order steaks during the pandemic, when I couldn’t visit my local butcher shop. During this time, I checked out various sites and graded each one of them based on quality, selection, and more.

In this post, I will reveal the best mail order steaks that you can order online and give you a few shopping tips of your own!

best mail order steaks

The Best Mail Order Steak Companies

Here are the top brands that you should check out for mail order steaks:

1. Snake River Farms

Best Overall

Excellent Quality Meat

If you are looking for the very best quality, then Snake River Farms is a company that you should turn to. For one thing, most of the Snake River Farms steaks are of American Wagyu standard, which sets them above USDA Prime beef. The rest of the steaks are USDA Prime or USDA or Choice, there is nothing lower than.

The cattle are carefully reared and they are antibiotics and hormone free. So, not only is your Snake River Farms meat safer, but you get to enjoy delicious steaks as a result of the great marbling content in the meat.

Of course, the price is rather high for such quality meat. So, you should be prepared to shell out a fair amount of money here.

Wide Selection of Steaks

The other thing that I was impressed with by Snake River Farms was the selection that they have. From a ribeye steak to a Delmonico steak, there is every kind of steak that you could want. I also like the fact that due to a larger operations, these steaks tend to be in stock when you want them.

Grilled Beef Steaks with Herbs and Spices

Quick Delivery Time

Depending on where you live and the delivery options that you choose, you can have your steak in a couple of days time with this company. What’s more, you have the option of placing the order up to two weeks before you need the steak, ensuring that it gets to you at the right time.


  • Great quality
  • Excellent selection
  • Great delivery services


  • Expensive

2. Omaha Steaks

Best Budget Option

Good Prices

One thing you will notice about mail order steak is that it can get rather pricey. So, if you are looking for a more affordable option, I would suggest Omaha Steaks to you.

Not only does this company tend to have cheaper prices than many other of the companies listed here, but they also tend to do some pretty good deals. So, you can often save when shopping for larger quantities of steak.

Decent Quality

Since you aren’t paying top-notch prices, you can’t expect top-notch quality either. That isn’t to say that the quality is poor with Omaha Steaks – in fact, it is the opposite. Not only is most of their fare decent quality, they also have some more expensive grass fed options too.

The issue is that the quality isn’t consistent. So, you can’t be too sure exactly what you are getting when you order from Omaha Steaks.

Good Selection of Steaks

The other great thing about Omaha Steaks is that it has a really good selection of steak. So, it doesn’t matter if you are craving sirloin or strip steaks, you will be able to find exactly what you are looking for.

As an added bonus, you can find other meats there including pork chops.


  • Good prices
  • Decent quality
  • Good selection


  • Inconsistent quality

3. Chicago Steak Company

Best for Filet Mignon

Great Quality Steaks

If you like the finer things in life like filet mignons, then you are likely only looking for the best of the best. Well, this is where the Chicago Steak Company website comes in.

This company is all about attention to detail when it comes to quality. For one thing, they only choose their meat from Mid-West raised cows and that meet the USDA Prime and 1/3 Upper Choice beef.

The steaks are carefully aged over a period of four to six weeks before they are sold to public. So, if you want a premium angus filet mignon, you are in the right place.

Great Selection of Steak

While the Chicago Steak Company definitely has the best filet mignon, their selection doesn’t end there. From strip steaks and ribeye to T-Bones, there are plenty of options for you to choose from. So, even if you are looking for cheaper options, you will be able to find them.

Roasted Beef Steak with Rosemary Leaves

Good Delivery Service

One of the things that I like about this mail order company is how quickly delivery can be arranged. Although you do have to pay more, you can have your steaks by the next day if you want. So, it is great for when you are in a pinch.

The only issue I had was that the ice that comes with the delivery starts dissolving quickly.


  • Great quality
  • Great selection
  • Quick delivery


  • Ice used in packaging dissolves a bit quickly

4. Holy Grail Steak Company

Best for Wagyu Beef

Best Wagyu Beef Quality

A lot of the Wagyu that you get in the states is American Wagyu. In short, it is good but doesn’t quite touch the quality that you get from the traditional Wagyu from Japan. Well, the Holy Grail Company has completely changed the game with Japanese Wagyu at a grading level of A5. So, you get the most delicious steak you can imagine.

As you can imagine, this is one of the priciest online retailers that you will come across.

Good Selection

This site may have the best quality steaks you have ever seen, but there is still a decent selection for you to choose from. In addition to top-of-the-lion filet mignons, you also get ribeye, tomahawk steaks, and more.

Quick Delivery

I do like how quickly the steaks can be delivered to you. If you are choosing a regular delivery option, then the processing and delivery time can take up to three days. However, if you spring for the overnight delivery, you can have your steaks delivered to you in one day!


  • Excellent quality
  • Good selection
  • Quick delivery


  • Expensive

5. Boxed Halal

Best for Halal Steaks

All Halal Steaks

If you live in a rural area then finding halal meats isn’t always easy. Luckily for you, all the steaks offered by Box Halal are just that. All the animals have been hand slaughtered. The necessary standards have been adhered to and the company has received its halal certification.

Good Quality Meat

What I like about Boxed Halal is that they go beyond simply just offering halal steaks. They also pay a great deal of attention to their quality as well. All the cows are grass fed and then grain finished. They are also not given any hormones or antibiotics.

Small Selection

Now, at this site, you can choose from a New York strip steak, a ribeye, and a filet mignon. Unfortunately, that is about the only choice that you have. So, if you are looking for a wider variety of steak, you will be limited to what it is in stock.

Medium Rare Ribeye Steak on the Wooden Board


  • Halal certified
  • Good quality meat
  • Common steaks available


  • Limited selection

6. Charm City Kosher

Best for Kosher Steaks

Kosher Grade Meat

It can be just as difficult to find good online meat delivery stores for kosher steak. So, if you are looking for a good steak and want to guarantee that it is kosher, I would suggest this site for you right here. All the food that they offer here is kosher.

Good Quality Meat

This company only works with small family farms to ensure that you get pasture raised beef. What’s more, the beef is all USDA certified and humanely raised as well.

Limited Selection

The only downside is that the steak selection on this site is limited. Due to this, you have to take whatever that you can get. On the other hand, you can get plenty of other types of kosher meat if you want.


  • Kosher certified
  • Good quality
  • Steak and other meat options


  • Limited selection

7. Porter Road

Best for Dry Aged Steaks

Excellent Dry Aged Steak

If you have had the opportunity to try dry aged beef, then you know what a difference this process can make to your steak. Luckily for you, all of the steaks at Porter Road are dry aged. As such, you get to enjoy a lovely, succulent taste each and every time.

Due to this long process, though, the steaks you want can sometimes be out of stock for a while.

High Quality Beef

I was quite impressed with the lengths that Porter Road goes to ensure that the cattle are cared for and to ensure that you get the highest quality meat. The cattle are grass fed beef but they are grain finished for a better flavor. The cattle are also allowed to roam free to improve their health. and quality of living.

Juicy Rump Steak with Herbs and Rosemary

Fresh Meat Delivery

Unlike many other brands, this company does not freeze their meat for shipping. They do pack the steaks in temperature controlled boxes but apart from this, the meat arrives thawed and ready for you to cook.


  • Dry aged steak
  • High quality meat
  • Fresh meat delivery


  • Can take a while to re-stock items

8. Kansas City Steak Company

Best for Bulk Orders

Great for Steak Bundles

If you want to buy steaks for a large number of people or simply like to stock up on your meat, then this is the service for you. They have bundles and sets for you to choose from, allowing you to buy in bulk and for rather reasonable prices as well.

Wide Selection of Meat

As you would imagine, you do get Kansas City strip steaks from this site. In addition to the Kansas City steaks, though, you also get popular cuts like the ribeye as well as hanger steak. So, you should have no trouble finding what you need.

The only hiccup here is that there is limited information about where the beef is sourced from so the quality can be a bit unreliable at times.

Quick Delivery

I love how quick the delivery can be with this site. You can pay extra and have the meat delivered overnight or within two days time if you are looking for a slightly cheaper option. You can also choose when you want the steak delivered to your home.


  • Large quanitites at good prices
  • Large selection
  • Quick delivery


  • Quality can be unreliable

9. Rastelli’s

Best for Sirloin Steaks

Great Selection

The selection on this site is really impressive. The sirloin steaks are exceptionally good. However, if you are also in the mood for ribeye steak, filet mignon, top sirloin, you will be able to find it without any issue at all.

Excellent Quality

The quality offered by this site is nearly unbeatable. For one thing, almost all their meat comes from grass fed cows. For another, they even have organic options which is pretty unusual in this market.

Grilled Beef Steak on a Hot Plate

Reasonable Shipping Charges

Not only do you get free shipping for amounts over $200, the shipping charges for this site, in general, are really reasonable. And, the more that you order, the less that it costs.

The only downside is that the processing and shipping does take a longer period of time.


  • Great selection
  • Excellent quality
  • Reasonable shipping charges


  • Long processing time

10. ChopBox

Best for NY Strip Steaks

Great Selection

Now, this site is known for its New York strip steaks, but it does have a wide selection of steaks to choose from. This includes everything from a Tomahawk steak to a hanger steak.

Good Quality Meat

All the cows are raised in farms in Arizona and they are all fed a vegetarian diet. They are also not given any hormones or antibiotics.

Quick Shipping

The meat is shopped to you really quickly so if you are in a pinch, you should get the meat within a day or two of your ordering it!

The only downside is that shipping can get a little pricey for certain states.


  • Great selection
  • Good quality meat
  • Quick shipping


  • Shipping can get expensive

How to Choose the Best Mail Order Steak Company?

Here are the top tips to follow to find the best company for you:

Pay Attention to Quality

You should always start your search off by looking at the quality of the meats. Only consider companies that have a USDA certification. Now, as you may be aware, there are three categories for USDA beef – Prime, Choice, and Select.

Personally, I would advise you to only stick with online companies that offer USDA Prime or Choice. Select isn’t bad, but this is a category that you can easily get at your local grocery store or butcher shop.

As you are making the effort to ship the steaks in, it is best to go with higher quality options. Not to mention, this also guarantees that you will get steaks with better flavor and texture.

Consider How the Cattle is Raised

True steak lovers know that how animals are raised can play a big role in the quality of the meat. Not to mention, it also shows you how healthy the meat is as well.

Whenever possible, look for farm raised animals. They live in better, more humane conditions. Not only is this better for the animal, but the proper living conditions can lower the risk of stress and disease.

The other thing that you should check on is the diet. Now, grass fed cattle who are then grain fed towards the end of their life offer the best tasting meat.

However, I wouldn’t get too hung up on choosing a company that only grass feeds their cattle. While grass should make up much of their diet, it is also fine if the cattle are fed other healthy alternatives.

Last but not least, make sure that the cows are free of hormones and antibiotics.

Check the Selection

You don’t have to go with a company that has a large selection. It is more important that the company keeps the kind of steak you want in stock.

That being said, if you are someone who doesn’t have a favorite or likes to switch things up, I would suggest checking that there is a good balance between the more affordable steaks as well as the more high end options.

Delicious Beef Steak with Herbs and Tomatoes

Compare the Prices

As you can imagine, quality plays a role when it comes to prices. So, stores that offer more premium quality steaks will naturally charge more.

That being said, you shouldn’t take the prices at face value. Instead, look for companies that provide the same level of quality. Then, compare their prices for specific steaks at specific weights. This will ensure that you are getting the best deal possible.

Look at the Processing and Delivery Times

When it comes to online stores, the processing and delivery times can be anywhere from a couple of days to a whole week. You should also consider the fact that some businesses don’t deliver on weekends or Sundays.

There are some stores that will provide you with overnight or one day delivery at a higher price.

Whenever you see these timings, always check the combined processing and delivery time. This is because although delivery may just take a day or two, the processing can be longer.

If you want to ensure that your steaks arrive precisely when you want them, look for stores that allow you to place orders for specific dates ahead of time.

Check the Delivery Packaging Method

Each store has its own way of shipping the meat to you. Some stores choose to send their fresh steaks as is.

The upside of this is that the taste and texture don’t interfere in any way. Unfortunately, there are also some food safety concerns here as the steaks may be stored at higher temperatures for certain periods of time.

In this case, it is important for the steaks to come with dry ice and with appropriately insulated packaging.

If the steaks are frozen and they are being transported over a greater distance, make sure that these too are packed with dry ice and in proper containers.

The Final Verdict

There is no denying that Snake River Farms is the best option due to its quality, selection, and its quick delivery times.

Still, make sure to check out all the sites in this post. They each have their own unique features and perks and you can never tell which one might be the best fit for you! Good luck in finding your top steaks online!

By Kristy J. Norton
I'm Kristy – a chef and connoisseur of all things BBQ! You can find me either in my kitchen (or someone else's) or at a big outdoor barbecue surrounded by friends and family. In both my professional and personal life I’ve picked up more than a few tips and tricks for turning out delicious food. I consider it a privilege to share it with others!
Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Pitmaster Central is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for website owners to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon (.com, .co.uk, .ca etc) and any other website that may be affiliated with Amazon Service LLC Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Keep Reading
Copyright 2024 Pitmaster Central, all rights reserved.